Was how he played on Sunday enough to change anyones mind?
I thought he played brilliantly and I dont just mean that breakaway try. He threw some brilliant passes and is really showing a bit of his class now I said at the time it was just a matter of time while the rest of the team got used to how he passes and now they have look how good it is.

Now i'm not saying hes immense I'm just asking if everyone is still intent on him being the new scapegoat or has anyone been turned?

I put a poll on b'coz they're fun...

I ve never had any doubt about his ability he was out for 6 to 8 month with a serious neck injury . So of course it was gonna take time you don't get picked for origin games for being rubbish . It has made me laugh the amount of poop what been said about him when you consider the neck problem he had .

A good player and getting better, has stated already the neck injury was very severe and could have cost him his career or maybe worse if it had not been corrected.

So I for one am glad that he is playing for us and game by game has started to get it together on the pitch!

Was always going to be a class act. Hopefully a few idiots will quieten down now

Form is temporary, class is permanent.

Going to be a cracking player for us in the run in - but I do think his defence looks suspect at times.

Correct. You don't become a Melbourne first team regular through luck. Will be a cracker once he gets into the swing!

Showing glimpses of class but still massive improvement in him.

I think, it was a case of him trying too hard, you can see that he's more relaxed now, and he's form is picking up.

I thought he was a great player when he arrived here but needed needed to pick up some form very quickly otherwise it could cost us. I think he's been pretty good over the last few weeks but I thought he was crap against Bradford! It's a crazy world.

No brainer, quaility player who needed time...

class is permanent and form is fleeting.

I put him in the same bracket as Buderus and Menzies